Should Young Soccer Players Take Creatine or Protein Powder? What the Research Says

Should Young Soccer Players Take Creatine or Protein Powder? What the Research Says

Roman PivarnikReviewed by Roman PivarnikUEFA Pro Licence · Technical Director, Slovak FA

No pediatric body recommends creatine or protein powder for a young soccer player. The American Academy of Pediatrics is blunt about it: shortcuts like performance-enhancing supplements "are of little benefit and can be dangerous," and "most young athletes who eat a healthy, well-balanced diet do not need and would not benefit from protein supplements." And yet the small body of research on creatine in adolescent athletes was done almost entirely on soccer players and swimmers, and it found short-term performance gains with no adverse events reported. Both of those things are true at once, which is why the honest answer for a 13-year-old is food, sleep and a real strength plan first — and a conversation with your pediatrician before anything else.

This question usually arrives in November. The season just ended, the off-season strength work starts, a teammate's older brother has a tub of something in the kitchen, and your son or daughter asks whether they should be taking it too.

Here is what the actual sources say — the pediatricians, the NIH, and the handful of studies that have ever been run on players this age.

What do pediatricians actually say about supplements for young athletes?

The AAP's parent-facing guidance on performance-enhancing sports supplements, last updated in October 2026, makes three points that matter more than anything on a label.

The products themselves are not what the label says. In the AAP's words: "dietary supplements are not regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Studies looking at the purity of supplements find high rates of contamination with possibly harmful substances. Also, many products do not contain the ingredients listed on the label." That is the single strongest argument against handing a tub to a 14-year-old, and it has nothing to do with the active ingredient.

The performance case in this age group is weak. "Studies have not shown these supplements help improve sports performance for them," the AAP writes of protein and creatine in young athletes, adding that during puberty players "grow and become stronger and their performance often improves very quickly," and that "creatine does not appear to offer any additional benefit in this age group."

Energy drinks are a separate, firmer no. The NIH's fact sheet on dietary supplements for exercise and athletic performance cites the AAP's position that caffeine-containing energy drinks "have no place in the diets of children or adolescents and are not suitable for use during routine physical activity," alongside the American Medical Association's recommendation that adolescents consume no more than 100 mg of caffeine a day.

Here is the summary, substance by substance.

Does it work in adults?Evidence in under-18sThe practical read
Protein powderYes, where total protein intake is shortNo benefit shown when diet is adequateA convenience food, not a performance product
CreatineStrong evidence for sprinting and repeated high-intensity efforts9 small studies total; short-term gains, no adverse events reportedWorks, but unresolved in this age group — a doctor's call, not a teammate's
Caffeine / energy drinksVariable; effects "not as well studied in children" (AAP)AAP: no place in the diets of children or adolescentsNo
Testosterone boostersNo evidence of benefitNoneNo, in every case
Vitamins and mineralsNo performance gain in well-fed athletesSameOnly to correct a deficiency a doctor found

Does a young soccer player need protein powder?

Almost certainly not — but it's worth knowing the numbers rather than guessing at them.

The recommended dietary allowance for protein is 0.85 g per kg of body weight per day for adolescents, according to the NIH fact sheet. For athletes, more recent data cited in that same sheet suggests a daily intake of 1.2 to 2.0 g/kg "to support metabolic adaptations, muscle repair and remodeling, and protein turnover." After a session, the joint position of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, Dietitians of Canada and the American College of Sports Medicine is 0.3 g/kg of high-quality protein — about 20 g for a 150-pound player — within 0 to 2 hours, then again every 3 to 5 hours.

Two things follow from that.

The first is that 20 g is a meal, not a product. A player who eats properly after training hits these numbers without a scoop of anything, which is exactly the AAP's point. Our guide to what a youth soccer player should eat before and after training covers what that actually looks like on a Tuesday night.

The second is that the magic window is smaller than the marketing suggests. A meta-analysis cited in the NIH sheet found that ingesting protein within an hour before or after exercise "does not significantly increase muscle strength or size or facilitate muscle repair or remodeling."

There is one real exception the AAP names: vegetarian players "may be at risk of not eating enough protein and may benefit from meal planning with a registered dietitian." That is a dietitian referral, not a tub.

Does creatine work for young soccer players?

In adults, yes, and unambiguously for soccer's energy demands. The NIH fact sheet concludes that short-term creatine supplementation "often significantly increases strength... power... and sprinting and soccer performance," and describes a randomized study in 14 female collegiate soccer players during the off-season who took 15 g/day for a week then 5 g/day for 12 weeks and gained significantly more bench-press and full-squat strength than the placebo group.

In adolescents, the entire evidence base is nine studies — and this is the part that should interest soccer parents specifically. A 2021 review of creatine supplementation in children and adolescents found that every performance study ever published in this age group had been done in just two sports: five in swimming and four in soccer. Among the four soccer studies, lasting 7 to 49 days:

  • Three short loading-phase studies reported significant gains — in repeat sprinting and dribbling, in a dribbling test plus countermovement jump and sprint power, and in peak and mean power on a Wingate test.
  • The one longer study, seven weeks with a loading phase and a six-week maintenance dose in 14 male adolescent players, found no improvement in lower-body power.
  • All were placebo-controlled, and across all of them "creatine was well tolerated with no adverse events being reported."

So: four small studies, one of them null, mostly on international male players, nearly all measuring short-term effects. That is a thin basis for a decision about your child.

Is creatine safe for a 14-year-old?

This is where the honest answer is "nobody has actually tested it," and where you should be wary of anyone who sounds certain in either direction.

The 2021 review states it plainly: "no studies have been published examining safety considerations in healthy young or adolescent athletic populations." Its authors argue that there is no reason to expect a different safety profile than in adults, note that creatine-related reports made up only 22 of 15,274 adverse-event reports in the FDA's reporting system over 2018–2020, and point out that the FDA has designated creatine "generally recognized as safe" — a designation they argue extends to older children and adolescents. They also say outright that "an absence of self-reported adverse events by study subjects is not a confirmation of safety," and that randomized safety trials in this age group are "desperately needed."

Two caveats belong next to that, and most pages on this topic leave them out.

One study in youth soccer players found something worth asking a doctor about. In a 2019 randomized, double-blind trial, 19 elite players (13 under 18, 6 under 21) took creatine for eight weeks. The researchers found trends toward increased airway inflammation and reduced lung function versus placebo, and concluded that "we cannot exclude that creatine supplementation has an adverse effect of the airways of elite athletes, particularly in those with allergy sensitization." If your child has asthma or allergies, that is a specific thing to raise.

Check who paid for the review. The 2021 paper's own disclosures state that the article processing charge was funded by Alzchem, a creatine manufacturer, and that the authors "received financial remuneration for preparing and reviewing this paper from the sponsor of the special issue." That doesn't make its findings wrong — it is a careful, useful review, and the disclosure is right there in the paper — but it is the kind of thing a parent is entitled to weigh. The AAP has no comparable interest in whether you buy a tub, and it says no.

Why does the label say "not for under 18" if a store will sell it to a 15-year-old?

Because the label is a liability notice, not a rule anyone enforces — and retail staff routinely talk straight past it.

Researchers posing as 15-year-old high school athletes called 244 health food stores across the United States and asked what to take to get stronger. The results, published in Pediatrics in 2017 as Dietary Supplements and Young Teens:

  • 67.2% of sales attendants recommended creatine — 38.5% brought it up unprompted.
  • 74.2% said a 15-year-old could buy it himself in the store.
  • 9.8% recommended a testosterone booster, and 41.4% said a 15-year-old could buy one.

The researchers' own conclusion was that retailers and state legislatures "should also consider banning the sale of these products to minors." Whatever you decide about creatine, a testosterone booster recommended to a teenager by a shop assistant is a straightforward no.

What actually makes a young soccer player stronger and faster?

The unglamorous things, all of which are free.

Puberty. As the AAP notes, players grow and get stronger quickly during this period on their own. It is also why a good player can suddenly look clumsy for a few months — our piece on growth spurts and soccer performance covers what is actually happening and what not to panic about.

A real strength programme. Resistance training works in this age group when it is coached properly, and the age it should start is a more useful question than the supplement one: see strength training for youth soccer players.

Sleep. The most under-used performance lever any teenager has, and the one with the clearest evidence behind it. We covered the numbers in how much sleep youth soccer players need.

Touches on the ball. Nothing in a tub improves a first touch. The gap between a good player and a very good one at 14 is almost always built in the hours between team practices — the kind of short, structured daily work FlickTec packages into sessions a player can actually do on their own.

How should I handle it when my child asks?

A workable sequence, in order:

  1. Audit the food first. Three meals, a real post-training meal, and enough calories for a growing athlete who trains four times a week. Most "I need a supplement" conversations are actually an eating-enough conversation.
  2. Ask the pediatrician, not the internet or the store. They know your child's growth curve, allergies and asthma history — the things that make the airway finding above relevant or irrelevant.
  3. Draw the hard lines now. No testosterone boosters, no energy drinks, no pre-workout. The AAP's position on energy drinks is unambiguous, and the AMA's 100 mg/day caffeine ceiling for adolescents is easy to blow past with one scoop of pre-workout.
  4. If an adult decision is made to proceed, treat contamination as the main risk. The purity problem the AAP describes is the thing most likely to hurt a young player, so third-party testing matters more than the brand on the front.
  5. Revisit it at 18, not at 14. The adult evidence is genuinely strong. It will still be there.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is creatine safe for teenagers?

No study designed to test safety has ever been run in healthy adolescent athletes. A 2021 review of the research in children and adolescents found no adverse events reported across the small number of performance studies that exist, and argued creatine is likely safe in this group — while also stating that an absence of reported adverse events is not confirmation of safety and that randomized safety trials are urgently needed. The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend creatine for young athletes. That makes it a question for your child's pediatrician rather than one to settle from a label.

How much protein does a teenage soccer player need?

The recommended dietary allowance is 0.85 g per kg of body weight per day for adolescents. Athletes are generally advised to take in 1.2 to 2.0 g/kg per day, with about 0.3 g/kg of high-quality protein — roughly 20 g for a 150-pound player — within two hours after exercise and again every three to five hours. Those targets are reachable through normal meals, which is why the AAP says most young athletes who eat a well-balanced diet do not need protein supplements.

Does my 12-year-old need protein powder?

No. The AAP's position is that most young athletes eating a healthy, balanced diet neither need nor benefit from protein supplements, and that studies have not shown these products improve sports performance in this age group. The exception the AAP names is vegetarian players, who may be at risk of not eating enough protein and may benefit from meal planning with a registered dietitian.

Does creatine actually improve soccer performance?

In adults, yes — the NIH concludes that short-term creatine supplementation often significantly improves strength, power, sprinting and soccer performance. In adolescents the evidence is four small placebo-controlled soccer studies: three short ones found gains in repeat sprinting, dribbling, jump and sprint power, while a seven-week study found no improvement in lower-body power. It is a thin evidence base, and most of it measures only the first week.

Can a 15-year-old buy creatine in a store?

In practice, usually yes, despite label warnings against use by under-18s. When researchers posing as 15-year-old athletes called 244 US health food stores, 74.2% of sales attendants said a 15-year-old could buy creatine himself, 67.2% recommended it, and 41.4% said he could buy a testosterone booster. Assume the store is not the safeguard.